Search  
      About          Contact          Archives          Subscribe         

Features
Perspectives
Interview
The Pulpit
Harvard Exclusive



 
Gallup Presents: Russian Muslims
Religious Leaven in a Secular Society by Sergei Gradirovski, Neli Esipova

Sergei Gradirovski is the Director of the Center for Strategic Research of the Volga Region Federal District and a Research Advisor for the Gallup World Poll.
Neli Esipova is a Senior Consultant at the Gallup Organization and the Regional Research Director for Former Soviet Union countries for the Gallup World Poll.

Islam in Russia is full of surprises. It suffered serious human and institutional losses during periods of extreme intolerance. In the nineteenth century, for example, Tsarist Russia rested on "orthodoxy, autocracy, populism"-the three "root essences" of Russian society put forth by Count Sergey Uvarov, the president of the Russian academy of Sciences, in 1833. Muslims in the north Caucasus region at times resisted two of those pillars-adherence to the Russian Orthodox Church and submission to Russian rule-and suffered persecution for their resistance. Under the Soviet Union's cult of militant atheism all religions were suppressed, and Islam was certainly no exception. The character of Islam in Russia has been affected for centuries by its close proximity to Slavic and Finno-Ugric cultures. But despite such challenges, the faith has survived in Russia, and its tenacity speaks to the devotion of the country's Muslim communities.

For the first time in 2007, the Gallup Poll provided a rare look at Russia's estimated 15 to 20 million Muslims. Gallup asked respondents in Russia: "do you consider yourself to be religious, or not?" those responding affirmatively were then asked for their religious affiliation. In addition to the national sample, supplementary interviews were conducted in two regions, Dagestan and Tatarstan, with high concentrations of Muslim residents. The resulting sample contained a total of 673 Russian Muslims.

Do Russian Muslims Adhere to Islamic traditions?

Perhaps the most obvious question regarding Muslims in Russia is the degree to which they adhere to traditional Islamic beliefs and practices in an environment where religious expression has been suppressed for so long. Gallup asked Muslim respondents about four of the five "pillars" of Islam, the five ritual practices considered the duty of every Muslim.

1. Namaz. About half of Russians identifying as Muslims (49 percent) say they never perform namaz, the ritual prayer in supplication to Allah. Among young Russian Muslims-those aged between 15 and 24-this number reaches two-thirds (66 percent). These figures are notable in light of the fact that calling oneself a Muslim and never performing namaz would be nonsensical in the Middle East or any other region of the Islamic world.

On the other hand, many Russians would be astonished by the fact that as many as 16 percent of Muslims living in the country perform namaz five times a day exactly as commanded, a difficult requirement for anyone involved in the mad rhythm of modern life. Furthermore, half (50 percent) of Russian Muslims feel it is necessary to create areas for namaz in public places and establishments, such as train stations, airports, universities, and institutes.

2. Shahadah. Just over half of Russian Muslims (54 percent) were able to correctly complete the Shahadah, the ritual Muslim declaration of faith, once the interviewer began it. Given that the Shahadah is considered the most fundamental of the five pillars, this figure may seem low to many in the Muslim world. Consider, however, that by comparison, only 13 percent of Russian orthodox respondents could continue the first lines of the Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed, the obligatory ecumenical church chanted within the framework of every liturgy.

3. Ramadan. Thirty-five percent of Russian Muslims say they do not fast during the sacred month of Ramadan, and another 34 percent say they fast "as much as possible" during that time. Only about one in four (28 percent) say they "fully" observe the Ramadan fast as required by Islamic law.

4. Hajj. Only 5 percent of Russian Muslims said they had already performed the Hajj, the pilgrimage to Mecca that Muslims are obliged to make at least once in their lifetime. The remaining 95 percent were asked to indicate the extent to which they would like to perform the Hajj. About a third (37 percent) indicated that they wanted very much to perform the Hajj by giving the highest rating on a five point scale, while 18 percent say they have no desire to do so, giving the lowest rating.

Findings regarding Islamic dietary restrictions also give some idea of the extent to which Russian Muslims adhere to traditional Islamic precepts:

* 27 percent of Russian Muslims say that it is not important to them that they eat halal food (food that is permissible under Islamic law), while 16 percent indicate they do not even know what halal food is.

* Half (50 percent) say they drink alcohol more or less frequently. Of the remaining 49 percent who say they never use alcoholic beverages, only 16 percent say that they do this for specifically religious reasons. However, 47 percent of these people do admit that abstaining from drinking is a personal ethical decision. Among those Russian Muslims who do drink hard alcohol, about half (52 percent) say they drink vodka-a sharp point of distinction from other Muslims worldwide, who rarely ever drink vodka-but a cultural commonality that links them to other communities in the cold expanses of Northern Eurasia.

* Almost a third of Russian Muslims (27 percent) acknowledge that they eat pork. In the Volga and the Urals, the places inhabited by the Tatars and the Bashkirs, pork is referred to-not without irony- as the "meat of the white lamb." this tolerance of forbidden food may have roots not only in the persecutions of the Soviet period, but also in the prevalence of the Russian secular tradition of drawn-out celebratory feasts. It may also be the result of close proximity to the Slavic and Finno-Ugric peoples, who include pork in their daily diets.

The Role of Islam in Society

Overall, responses to questions addressing the role of Islam in society also suggest Russian Muslims hold views consistent with relatively moderate Muslim populations, though they may be considered less moderate by non-Muslims in Russia. When asked "what influence should religion have on political decisions in the country?" about one-third of Russian Muslims indicated religion should not be on the sidelines, saying it should have "the most important" (8 percent) or a "major" (26 percent) influence. Conversely, 25 percent said it should have a minor influence, and 32 percent said it should have no influence at all. Responses from Orthodox Christians were similar: 29 percent said religion should have the most important or a major influence, 30 percent said it should have a minor influence, and another 30 percent said it should have no influence at all.


 




© 2003-2008 The Harvard International Review. All rights reserved.